Traverse Insights

Recent PCAOB revelations uncover rising audit deficiencies in major US accounting firms, spotlighting a critical talent shortage. Explore the implications for the industry and the path forward.

The recent revelations by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) regarding the increased audit deficiencies among some of the largest accounting firms in the United States have cast a spotlight on a critical issue facing the accounting industry. Notably, the U.S. units of Deloitte, EY (Ernst & Young), and PwC (PricewaterhouseCoopers) reported an average audit deficiency rate of 24% for the year 2021, a significant rise from the previous year's 13%. This uptick in audit deficiencies is not just a statistical anomaly but a symptom of deeper, systemic challenges within the accounting profession, particularly the acute shortage of accounting talent and the difficulties in attracting new entrants to the field. 

​

Additionally the significant uptick in financial restatements by public companies in 2021, particularly influenced by challenges associated with Special Purpose Acquisition Companies (SPACs), can also be viewed through the lens of a burgeoning talent shortage in the accounting and finance sectors. The surge to 1,470 companies filing restatements, a 289% increase from the previous year, underscores not just regulatory or procedural challenges but also points to the broader issue of expertise gaps within the industry. This talent deficit, especially in handling complex accounting standards and financial reporting requirements, exacerbates the potential for misstatements and errors. While SPAC-related accounting issues, such as the misclassification of certain shares, were at the forefront of these restatements, a deeper look reveals a landscape struggling with the adequate application of evolving accounting standards due to a shortage of skilled professionals.

​

The Audit Quality Conundrum

The PCAOB's recent findings ring alarm bells for several critical reasons. Initially, they indicate a worrying decline in audit quality, which is paramount to the financial markets' integrity. Audits are designed to assure stakeholders of the accuracy and reliability of financial statements, serving as a cornerstone of investor confidence and the effective distribution of resources within the economy. An audit deficiency means the auditing firm did not gather enough evidence to confidently endorse the financial statements, possibly overlooking inaccuracies or misrepresentations. The growing prevalence of such deficiencies suggests that even the most reputable accounting entities are facing difficulties upholding the high standards expected of them.

The situation is starkly illustrated by EY's U.S. operation, which exhibited a deficiency rate of 46% across 54 audits reviewed by the PCAOB. This is not merely a minor concern but a significant red flag indicating profound issues within the firm's audit processes and methodologies. The PCAOB pinpointed deficiencies in critical areas such as the testing of controls over revenue and related accounts, business combinations, and inventory management. These areas are crucial to the audit process, raising serious questions about the thoroughness and rigor of the conducted audits.

​

The Talent Shortage Crisis

Underpinning this decline in audit quality is the significant challenge of a talent shortage within the accounting industry. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports that more than 300,000 U.S. accountants and auditors have left their jobs in the past couple of years, marking a 17% decline in overall industry employment. This exodus is exacerbated by the looming retirement of a large portion of the workforce, with the American Institute of CPAs estimating that 75% of certified public accountants are retiring or close to retiring in the next 15 years.

​

The talent shortage is a multifaceted problem. On one hand, experienced accountants are increasingly moving into new roles in finance and technology, attracted by the promise of more dynamic work environments and, often, better compensation. On the other hand, the accounting profession is facing difficulties in attracting new entrants. Top-ranked university accounting programs are seeing declining enrollments, and a significant portion of accounting majors are choosing not to pursue careers in accounting upon graduation.

​

The Root Causes

Several factors contribute to the difficulty in attracting new talent to the accounting profession. Firstly, the perception of accounting as a less lucrative and less flexible career path compared to emerging fields like data science and technology is a significant deterrent. The Burning Glass Institute reports that the median starting salary for graduates working in accounting was $66,504 in 2021, compared to $97,562 in data science and $101,401 in tech. While accounting firms have raised salaries in recent years, they have not kept pace with the increases seen in these other fields.

​

Furthermore, the rigorous academic and testing requirements to become a certified public accountant, including the need to complete 150 credit hours and pass the CPA exam, represent significant barriers to entry. These requirements, while designed to ensure a high level of proficiency and professionalism within the industry, may dissuade potential entrants who are looking for quicker or less demanding paths into the workforce.

​

The Impact on Audit Quality

The talent shortage has direct implications for audit quality. With fewer experienced professionals available, the pressure on existing staff increases, potentially leading to the kind of deficiencies observed by the PCAOB. Moreover, the industry's capacity to innovate and adapt to new technologies and regulatory requirements is compromised, further affecting the quality and integrity of audits.

​

The response from the industry has been to acknowledge the problem and pledge improvements. Firms are investing in technology and training to enhance audit quality. For example, PwC's U.S. unit announced it would stop providing certain consulting work to its audit clients to avoid potential conflicts of interest, and EY's U.S. unit has initiated an in-depth review of its audit practice following the PCAOB's findings. However, these measures, while necessary, do not address the underlying issue of attracting and retaining talent.

​

Looking Ahead

Addressing the audit deficiency and talent shortage issues requires a holistic approach. The accounting industry must not only focus on improving audit practices and methodologies but also make the profession more attractive to new entrants. This could involve reevaluating compensation structures, providing more flexible career paths that allow for specialization in emerging and high-demand areas of accounting, and emphasizing the critical role accountants play in the economic and financial stability of markets globally. Moreover, there's a pressing need to modernize the perception of accounting as a career, showcasing its evolution into a field that integrates technology, analytics, and strategic thinking. Engaging with educational institutions to update curriculum could spark interest among students by highlighting the dynamic aspects of accounting and its importance in addressing contemporary business challenges.

Furthermore, the industry should consider advocating for regulatory reforms that could streamline the path to becoming a certified public accountant. Simplifying the certification process without compromising the quality and integrity of the profession could make accounting more accessible to a broader audience. Initiatives to support work-life balance, including remote work options and flexible scheduling, can also play a significant role in attracting and retaining talent.

Investments in technology will be crucial not only for improving audit efficiency and quality but also for making the profession more appealing. The adoption of artificial intelligence, machine learning, and data analytics tools can transform the audit process, making it more insightful and less manual. This technological shift can also open up new career paths within accounting firms for professionals interested in tech-driven financial analysis.

Additionally, partnerships between the accounting industry and technology companies could foster innovation in audit methodologies, ensuring that audits are more thorough and reflective of the complex financial instruments and transactions in today’s economy. Such collaborations could also provide valuable training and development opportunities for accountants, keeping them at the forefront of emerging trends and regulations. 

​

The path forward for the accounting industry involves a multifaceted strategy that addresses both the immediate challenges of audit deficiencies and the long-term need for attracting and retaining talented professionals. By embracing change, fostering innovation, and promoting inclusivity, the accounting profession can ensure its relevance and vitality in the rapidly evolving global financial landscape.